INTRODUCTION
This is a post a long time coming... I feel I've thought about it long enough to attempt a writing. Don't think I can get any further just by thinking. Now, to explain what this is going to be about: A lot of times, I'll tell people about friends I've met on the Internet and I'll get a weird look. I think my parents have outgrown this stage, but extended family and random people I meet will still give me the eyebrows when I talk about "a friend on the Internet." A few times, I'll be involved in a discussion with someone and Myst comes up and I'll just casually toss out there "yeah, I'm a Myst fan... I was part of the community, but I'm not anymore" and people will naturally ask why and I have to disappoint them with a pause and an "it's complicated." This is even to people who know me and know that I was big into Myst and ask me if I'm going to the "Myst convention" this year and I'm left explaining to them why... For all these people, and others who might be confused as to my status toward certain people, this post is for you. Now, before I begin, I want to say in advance that I currently intend no ill will toward anyone in particular. I may give examples of things that have happened to me, and the people I'm writing the examples from may read this and get angry. I say right now that I will give no names and all examples will be purely anonymous... If you get upset and leave a comment, then it will be your own doing that people begin to associate the examples toward you. That being said, let us begin!
FORMING RELATIONSHIPS
And by "relationship", I mean it in its broadest sense. Think "Sims relationship". Your Sim meets a new person and TADA! New relationship icon appears. One of the most common things people bring up when the subject of Internet friends appears is "how do you know they are who they say they are?" The simple fact of the matter is: You don't. People think that makes chat rooms and forums and Internet friendships based on nothing, and while that could be entirely accurate, and has been shown to be accurate before with all the news articles about stalkers and kidnappers, I tend to say that ALL friendships could be based on nothing.
Think about it... You meet a friend's friend. You've never seen them before, but you manage to strike up a conversation and learn some things about them. While your friend could be there to referee, so to speak, you're still taking this person's information at face value. None of it could be true, and, in fact, your own friend might be duped into believing false information, too. A lot of information can be corroborated with evidence and sometimes you can immediately see that some things are true and that some aren't.
Actually, a more appropriate example would be someone you've met at a bar. Now, for sake of those with overactive imaginations (like myself), I'm not referring to downtown strip clubs or places where people enjoy going to get drunk. I'm talking good old fashioned taverns and inns and places that people like to gather at the end of the day to wind down with a pint of ale and a good bit of gossip. Think hobbits! Anyway, back to the point: When you meet someone at a bar, there is absolutely no way you can be sure that what they're saying is true. They may say they're 18 or 28 or 38, or that they're visiting from Alabama, or that they are, in fact, not married... You can't be sure. Now, most of the time, people in bars come and go and you never see the same person twice... But sometimes there's a group of people who keep coming back to the same bar at the same time and you start getting acquainted. It's just a natural tendency. Two people see each other for the fifth time and greet each other with a nod or a wave and things just progress from there. You may have spoken once before and you may have even got along very well with them! I'm not going to get into how friendships are formed... But you get the idea. You meet people in a public area and sometimes you'll make friends if you happen to talk to them a lot.
Now, some people I realize are going to read this and point at me and accuse me of arguing on their behalf when I say the Internet is like a bar. Yes... I think that's the best analogy. Why? Because you have to treat the Internet as a public area where absolutely anybody could be lurking. It's just wise not to take someone at their word when you have no idea who they are. It's just common sense not to disclose contact information to someone you just met... The fact that the Internet is accessable from your living room is not something to be terrified of. You just need to realize that it's a wild place and you need to use caution. As with meeting someone in real life, they may not be who they say they are. They might be older, they might live somewhere else, in fact, these days, they might not even be the same gender they claim they are... And this is in real life as well as the Internet!
I hope this section, at least, helps disperse some of the fears of "Internet friends" not being who they say they are. That's a given... There's nobody who should argue otherwise. But I disagree that the Internet is a new frontier... Sure, it's opened up a plethora of new methods to communicate, but there's nothing different about the core issues with meeting new friends: They could be lying through their teeth and you would have no way of knowing.
HOW I, PERSONALLY, FORM FRIENDSHIPS
Now this is some background on how I form friends so I can explain what happened between me and some good friends I had in the Myst community. It might even go to help dispell some confusing between the friends themselves. For example, I had a friend who knew something was wrong between us, but would never have a mind open enough to consider that they were just as much the cause of the problem as they thought I was. I eventually just gave up explaining what was happening and they, in frustration, blocked all communication with me and I've never heard from them since. We'll call this person EXAMPLE ONE. I will later attempt to explain how I don't at all feel bad about our falling out... The way I see it, we stopped being friends long before the actual disagreement and subsequent turn of the back.
I will be using CyanChat as an example of my forming friendships online because, to be honest, I don't have many friends online who I DIDN'T meet at CyanChat. I would log in and I would see new people... I would say "hi", but not much else. At this point, I watch them carefully. I just act like myself and see what they do in response. Sometimes we hit it off really well, sometimes we don't and it's a disaster. Two people, who I will from now on affectionately refer to as EXAMPLE TWO and EXAMPLE THREE, come to mind. I met these people and we sort of got off on the right foot, but there was an awkward tense feeling when we would talk. Just the way I would say something and they would respond. There was a mutual feeling of pressing buttons to see what would ignite the other into anger. These two people have always been a bothersome thorn in my side, though I've grown to ignore their trivial pursuits for my blowing my top, but even after I left the community, they seem to find it far more interesting to pester me on my blog. I'm sure there's a quote somewhere about how your enemies last longer than your friends, but, eh! Them's the breaks, and there's no way to get around people not liking each other sometimes. But let's get back on track: At this point (when I've just met someone), anything they say I treat very skeptically. It could be the absolute truth, but I'm not going to treat it as the truth for a while. If they can keep their stories straight for more than a week, it's usually a pretty good indication that they're either telling you the truth, or they're so good at creating a personality that they've planned their false lives entirely in advance. (In a place as obscure as CyanChat, the last bit is very unlikely.)
As a rule, though, I will never disclose real world contact information such as landline telephone numbers or street addresses unless there's a serious need for it. (Such as when I bought that Myst baseball cap from my good buddy lonelyto25 Richard.) Gender is usually something I'll formulate an opinion on as soon as I see the name, but it's not always verified until we elevate the friendship to voice-chat levels and I can hear their voice for myself. But, in short, when I first meet someone, I don't believe a word they say. I process it, sure, and I make notes so I can corroborate it with what they say later... If there are any inconsistencies, it's a good bet that they're lying to you about something. Sometimes you just never get into enough "serious" discussions to become more than an acquaintence with a name in a chat room, but sometimes you get into deep discussions about life, religion, politics or the universe in general and you really start to see exactly who someone is like even without knowing anything about their own personal lives or appearance. Personally, I think this is a brilliant way to become friends with someone, because appearance is so immaterial on the Internet that nobody cares how someone LOOKS, only what they THINK and SAY. You only care about their personality and their beliefs... The things that really matter.
MAINTAINING AN ONLINE FRIENDSHIP
You may think that a friendship is a friendship and that's that... Eh, I vehemently disagree. I think maintaining an online friendship for an extended period of time is a very difficult thing to do. Online friendships are very fragile, very accelerated relationships... By accelerated I mean that it takes far less to make or break a friendship. Let's say that you've met a friend in the real world and that you've been friends for a year or two. It could even be a college roommate... You see each other every day, you know exactly how to read the expressions of the other and everything's just fine. If you were to insult their beliefs on something, I've noticed that, while it does deeply hurt them at times, they are far less likely to bail on you and ignore you for the rest of time for that particular infraction. Partly because you HAVE to see each other every day, but also, I think, because physically meeting someone helps build more bonds of friendship than when you just meet someone's nickname online. The whole thing when I mentioned appearance not mattering is almost cancelled out completely because, without visualizing a living, breathing person behind that nickname, it's nothing more than a nickname to you... Sure, you KNOW there's a person behind that name, but there's no connecting that name to the person. The issue with anonymity on the Internet is partly what makes it so great, but is also equally responsible for making the Internet so BAD.
I have a friend in the real world who I only see for, eh... Maybe two days, once or twice a year. We've been friends for as long as I can remember and we never see each other. Sometimes I think I know that friend better than anyone I've met online. We've gone through some pretty sticky situations when we were young... I remember fighting over sandbox toys, forming temporary alliances with each other to specifically make someone feel left out, and getting so very angry over the good ol' Nintendo Entertainment System. I think that if I had as many problems with someone online as I've had with that friend, I would never have remained a friend. There's just something about having a friend in real life that makes the friendship more solid. We barely see each other, but we KNOW we're friends because of what we put ourselves through and lived to tell about it. It's an awesome thing of the past, now... "Remember that time when we didn't know how to divide the sandbox into thirds and fought over who would get the fourth?" We would fight so violently over stupid crap and yet we're still friends... I think that makes it all the better.
Online friends, on the other hand, from my experience, are an entirely other ball game. Without appearances, the power of words are magnified beyond comprehension. You can make or break an online friendship with a single sentence simply because there's nothing else to offset it. You can insult someone and walk off and literally never look back and go on with your life. Internet anonymity makes it THAT easy to break a relationship. Of course, there's also the chance that someone breaks a friendship and appears to never look back, but decides to change their identity and does, in fact, return. Internet anonymity makes it THAT easy to change your entire personal history for everyone. Now, that's not to say that online friends CAN'T break up over something like that... I've had my fair share of deadly scrapes and jabs and sometimes we managed to be mature enough to apologize and fix the problem. Sometimes, you just know something happened that shouldn't have and that all you need to do is admit that you were wrong and it will all go away. Sadly, the power of words to destroy a friendship does not work so well to repair one, but I'll get to that in a second. I want to give some examples of ways I think people can maintain an online friendship.
Talk... A lot. When you can't sit in the same room as the friend, you need to actually talk. Opening an instant messenger or chat room window and lurking there saying nothing just isn't going to cut it. Remember, words, even in real life, are incredibly powerful, but online, they're the life force of friendships. If you stop talking, then the friend might as well not be there at all, and, as all of us Sims players know, when a Sim hasn't seen friends in so long, they start getting lonely and they start losing relationships. In real world friendships, you can go to your friend's and "hang out". You can sit there and watch a movie or play a video game and not say a WORD but still feel like you've had decent social interaction with them. When you're online, sitting silent in the room is not going to work... However, DOING something WILL work. That's right... Play games. You don't have to talk, but there's social interaction going on. You know you're playing with your friend, so it's okay not to talk. In fact, you might not even want anyone to talk since you're concentrating so much on gathering those asteroid resources or pulling off that wicked sniper shot that makes everyone afraid to face you as an opponent. In my personal experience, there is not much else you can do to maintain an online friendship than by talking or playing an online game. If you're NOT talking or playing a game, then your friendship isn't being maintained in the least bit, even if you're both in the same chat room.
Now, there's another downside to all of this... Since interactions are so charged with a constant stream of words or gameplay, the time you spend apart is going to feel like ages, at least by personal experience. I think this is further affected by the fact that there's no person to associate the name with. I think meeting someone in the real world, even just once, will go a long way to sealing the deal on the friendship. That way, you can associate the name with something more solid than a bit of text that logs on and off. You'll talk and play a game and as with all things that are fun, you lose track of time and you have to stop... You naturally look forward to next time, but that can seem like a really like time, even if it's just a few days or weeks. In the real world, I can go months without seeing a friend of mine in the real world and still pick up where I left off once I see them again. Online, if someone goes without talking to me for months, then it's a safe bet that they've forgotten about me and moved on. Online friendships can deteriorate so quickly... Sometimes, very rarely, I'll not talk to someone for a very, very long time and then BAM! All of a sudden, they show up and we get back into things like it was no problem, but that doesn't happen very often.
DESTROYING AN ONLINE FRIENDSHIP
And that leads me right into what it takes for an online friendship to end. This will serve as an explanation for what happened between me and the Myst community as well as an example of how online friendships end badly... Everyone who regularly visits this site knows what lengths I can go to when I discuss the Myst community, and no doubt this section will be a post all to itself, but it has to be said.
I'm a very trusting person by nature... Very loyal, too. At first I'm not too trusting of people, but once I've decided to call someone a friend, I hold them to certain standards, as we all do. The single most important standard I have, which, consequently, is also not very difficult to break, is that they don't betray my trust. It's as simple as that. You want to be my friend? Sure! I'm all for it... Just don't make me regret it. If a friend, for any reason, decides to take advantage of me by lying to my face, then you can consider yourself on the black list for the rest of time. A friend who I will refer to as EXAMPLE FOUR fits into this perfectly... They, at one time, professed to be my friend. We talked it up and laughed and watched movies... We did everything we needed to keep the friendship going, but then, one day, out of the blue, this person accused me of something without even bothering to ask my side of the story. Just WHAM! "You should be ashamed of yourself." Things were said, things were straigtened out and EXAMPLE FOUR apologized for their rash behavior... I forgave them, but the damage was done. They clearly didn't think enough of me to ask why I did what I did, and they gave no assurance that it wouldn't happen again. My guard went up in a flash. Later, they blatantly insulted one of my prized projects without provocation or an apology, and, later still, when I was discussing philosophical topics with someone else entirely, proceeded to put things in my mouth when it was absolutely obvious (since there WAS, after all, a record of all my text) that I had never said such a thing. That's when I drew the line and no longer considered them a friend... They betrayed my trust, plain and simple.
Betraying my trust is what I would file my entire leaving the community under. Everybody knows my feelings about Uru... It's not my favorite game and I wouldn't hesitate to point out problems or give opinions that went against what the most influential community members believed. It wasn't as if I was a newcomer... I'd been in the community for almost 8 years and people knew the name "GermanShepherd". They KNEW who I was and that I had just as much of a right to give my opinions about Uru as they did, but in the spirit of what they called "tolerance", they very nearly unanimously declared that I and everyone who thought there was something wrong with Uru should leave the community because we were what was making it fail. All those friends I'd made in my 8 years suddenly turned their back on me... Those that didn't actually shun me outright simply didn't make any attempt to talk to me or acknowledge my presense. Those who agreed with me were very few... I still have them as friends, I might add, and only one of them is still involved in the community, if by very little. Sometimes, people would remember me and try to talk to me, but it all seemed to be a very thinly disguised way to get me to do something for them, and that would only make matters worse. I will also always remember that I used to pretend and play like I was a dog in CyanChat... I would tackle people and play fetch and such. (I mean, hey... You had to have fun somehow, right? We CyanChatters were a crazy awesome bunch.) But, for some reason, those same people called me a creep for pretending to be a dog... Things like that. Where something happens to cause people to change so much that they are no longer who I thought they were and then openly attack me for being who I always was. (This would be EXAMPLE TWO, to be exact... While we did scrape a few times, we did used to be friends a long time ago.)
Another specific way of ending an online friendship is the usual way of letting friendships die out... Stop interacting. For example (EXAMPLE ONE, to be exact... Remember them from the beginning?), I had an online friend who I was very close to. We would do almost literally everything together... We would watch shows and play games and chat it up all day long and we even shared the experience of being ignored by all our other friends, so we became friends not only because there was nobody else, but because we sympathized with each other and out of that first contact, we discovered we had so many of the same interests. We were so perfect that people would joke at us by saying we should just marry each other because we wouldn't find a more suitable partner. We were that close... But... My friend slowly started to show less and less of an interest in doing things with me. Games were all the same... Movies were all boring... There was nothing I could say to get them interested in doing things with me anymore and they would just totter off and do something on their own. Eventually, even just plain talking started to feel like pulling teeth until finally, we seemed to stop talking altogether. Then, in a final bout, I laid it all on their feet and told them if nothing was going to change, then it was going to be over with... We had the same argument that regurgitated the same excuses and reasons from both sides and it wound up with that friend blocking me. I honestly believe that I did all I could to keep things going, but my friend would actively resist all manner of things to have fun with, and would flat out not speak at all if I didn't go out of my way to speak to them.
CONSEQUENCES OF TERMINATED FRIENDSHIPS
Now, in either case, I'm not exactly upset that the friendships were terminated... The way I see it, the people who betrayed me were classic examples of what happens when you make friends with someone who lies to you. They painted a pretty picture and I made friends with the fake person, but as soon as I did something wrong in their eyes, the true person showed their ugly face... When that happens, I feel absolutely no regret knowing that our friendship died. As far as I'm concerned, I never knew you. I sincerely hope that the friends I have now are telling me the complete truths about themselves so I know who I'm being a friend with. I am perfectly honest with them and I expect them to be perfectly honest in return. There is no reason for me to distrust someone until they break it, so... Until they give me reason to doubt them, I will treat them as if what they say is true, and shame on them if they take advantage of that.
Now, when friendships die a slow death of neglect, that's what I have trouble with, as I have repeatedly told people, time and time again. I absolutely hate it when people stop talking to me... I try my hardest to keep friendships alive and unless someone betrays me, I consider friends of mine to be friends forever. As such, most of my friendships have simply been because my friend stopped talking to me... They changed their name and the contact information or don't pay attention to me anymore. These are the friendship failures that hurt... I regret whatever happened between us that made them stop talking to me. There were some who bit me when I tried to confront them about it, and for those, I feel less sorry about, but on the whole, I miss the friends who never gave me reason to doubt them, but decided to leave anyway. But for people who betray me, especially to such a magnitude as the Uru community, I wouldn't dignify you with a response if you begged me to return... You would have to somehow convince me that you wouldn't pull something like that on me again since you showed that you were perfectly capable of throwing someone under the truck to promote yourself.
CONCLUSION
So I hope this post will enlighten a few people into the intricacies of online friendships and maybe explain the way I feel about certain people and explain to some of them what happened between us. Some of them betrayed me and know they did, and thus won't care... Some of them betrayed me and don't know they did, but refuse to listen to me when I try to tell them, and thus don't care... Some of them betrayed me and know they did and have apologized and I've forgiven them, but there's still an air of caution when I interact with them. And, of course, the friends who've left me probably aren't reading this to begin with.
While I think online friendships are completely viable and no more or less safe than friendships formed under similar circumstances in the real world, I have no problem with admitting that there's a profound difference. I think it takes less to do more damage to an online friendship, but to have met an online friend in the real world will work wonders by letting you associate a person with the name, but it's also important, to me anyway, to realize that appearances don't matter, and that online friendships could potentially be far better due to the fact that you form friendships on personality only and not because someone looks pleasing to the eye.
If anyone has any doubts or questions or comments about anything, feel free to leave a comment. After all, this is a blog and the comments section IS open! That means, in no particular words: "POST A COMMENT, FOR THE LOVE OF ALL CREATION, LET ME KNOW YOU READ THIS PART OF THE INTERNET, PLEASE, I BEG OF YOU!" And with that, I conclude this post! (And I'm now very hungry...)